Two People Doing the Same Job Destroys Productivity. Here's Why.

Copyright (c) 2009 Bryan Becksteadtaking it upon himself to rethink your decision and
Productivity is all about getting the maximum amountreverse it and go off on his own, makes your entire
of production from the minimum amount of activity.management decision function redundant. How does it
That's why two people doing the same job destroysfeel to be made redundant?
any pretense of getting value from either person'sEvery time this happens in your company, your
involvement. Let's look at the classic example.business, your day to day living, you are forced to
You have been planning your day's activities, inspend at least twice as much time doing simple tasks
advance, as you should. You have decided that youbecause you are letting people make you redundant
want a specific person in your organization to performand unnecessary. How often does this happen to
a specific job and you have also time activated thatyou? You invest your time only to find out that when
activity to be done today between 10:00 AM andyou hand off the task or project to some one else, it
Noon. All is the way it should be.takes on a life of its own. This situation plays out a
You get to work and you relay your instructions tonumber of different ways but the end result is,
your employee and head off to do what you haveactivities take substantially longer to get done because
planned for the day. After lunch you decide to check inthe initial thought process was ignored.
on your employee and see how he did on that taskThe solution to this problem is simple; decide who is in
you had asked him to do. A quick glance and youcharge and let that person make the decisions. I said it
discover a disaster. Not only was the task that youwas a simple problem, not necessary an easy solution.
had asked to be done not done as you asked, butOne person per task, one person making the decisions,
your employee had taken it upon himself to do aneverybody does their job, things have a chance of
entirely unrelated task that had not been necessary, ingetting done on time and in a reasonable time frame. It
place of what you had asked and expected to besounds so simple but the reality is, very few
done. What had gone wrong?companies, businesses or organizations can
First, someone's time was now totally wasted. Eitheraccomplish it.
your time was now wasted, the time you spent onIn seminars when I caution people about running
planning, detailing, and organizing the task. Or yourcompanies with the "I thought" mentality, they get
employee had just wasted two hours doing a taskoffended and defensive. They counter with "people
you had not wanted done. This is the classichave a right to express themselves and they have a
productivity waste when two people decide to do theright to have their voice heard". I agree with all of that,
same job and in the end, the job is not done andexcept the part when all of this freedom of speech
everyone has to start from scratch.and sharing is suppose to take place. If you want to
In this case, when you approach the employee andget a reasonable return on your time, get production up
ask them why the initial job was not done, he or shewhere it should be, you have to start to get your
will invariably start off with the rationale of "I thought ..."people and yourself on the same page when it comes
detailing their reason why not doing what you wantedto setting the course and getting things accomplished.
and replacing it with a job of their choosing makesSomeone has to make the decisions and then
more sense. I wish I had a dollar for every time I havesomeone has to carry out those decisions, period. It's
heard that rationale.not a debating team you are running; it's a business.
"I thought" has no place in this situation. You, the personBryan Beckstead is the creator of the Power
in charge have already done the thinking in thisEmpowerment Group and has been involved in the
situation. The time has been spent on the thinking partTime Management and Productivity industries for
of this process; two people do not have toalmost 35 years.
independently think through this task. By your employee